From the October/November 2017 Issue  

What Shines Within

Writer Leslie Gilbert Elman
  • Although knife boxes had a function, they could be decorative objects in their own right, such as these lacquered cutlery boxes made in Japan around 1750 for a Dutch client. Oriental decoration became fashionable in the 17th century, and its popularity continued well into the 18th century. These boxes were offered for sale recently by Dutch antiques dealer A. Aardewerk Antiquair of The Hague. Courtesy of A. Aardewerk Antiquair

  • Made in England after 1770, these mahogany knife boxes are inlaid with deal, a wood related to pine. There’s a beaded molding around the base and the bottom of the lid and a compass star motif inlaid inside the lid. Courtesy of the Art Museums of Colonial Williamsburg

  • Dating from sometime after 1776, this mahogany knife box with a serpentine front and sloped lid was probably made in England, though possibly in America. Now part of the collection at George Washington’s estate, Mount Vernon, it holds 46 pieces of cutlery: 12 sets of knives and forks and an assortment of serving implements, including a marrow scoop. A 12-pointed star is inlaid on the top of the lid, and a similar six-pointed star surrounded by a circle is inlaid inside the lid. The fittings are silverplated metal. Courtesy of Mount Vernon

  • There’s a surprise inside these beautiful carved and reeded mahogany urns. Lift the gilded pineapple finial to reveal a tiered cylinder that holds a full set of cutlery. This neoclassical form originated in England and was later made in America, such as this pair from Baltimore circa 1820 owned by the Austen family of Maryland. Courtesy of the Art Museums of Colonial Williamsburg

Knife boxes were necessities for a well-appointed dining room.

At Mount Vernon, George Washington’s Virginia estate, tours of the house begin in the elegant New Room. (Completed in 1787, it’s “new” in relation to the rest of the house.) The neoclassical, gallery-style reception room is formal, yet comfortable, with personalized touches that symbolize Washington’s agricultural interests, such as plasterwork depictions of farm implements and crops on the walls and ceiling.

Large windows on three sides flood the room with light and allow cross-ventilation. The brilliant turquoise walls reflect the décor of the late 18th century. The New Room is where the former president and his wife would meet and entertain guests. It’s also where they hosted larger dinner parties, which explains the beautiful mahogany knife boxes prominently displayed on the sideboard.

Knife boxes, also called knife cases, were a fashion in England and America from the mid-18th century to the early 19th century. Made in pairs, they were fitted with inserts to hold forks, knives and serving utensils for formal meals and were designed to be portable so the serving staff could reset the table with fresh cutlery for each course. (Ironically, their portability also made them convenient to steal, and English newspapers of the time often carried reports of burglaries that included the theft of a knife box filled with valuable cutlery.)

The Mount Vernon household inventory conducted after Washington’s death included eight “knife cases” that would have been similar to the ones in the Mount Vernon collection today. Some must have held Washington’s prized silverware with Chinese porcelain handles—handles facing upward.

Farther south in Virginia, at the DeWitt Wallace Decorative Arts Museum, one of the Art Museums of Colonial Williamsburg, two pairs of 18th century knife boxes are part of the long-term exhibition “A Rich and Varied Culture: The Material World of the Early South.”

One is a pair of English mahogany boxes that came from a home in Charleston, South Carolina. They have the characteristic hinged, sloped lids that make traditional English knife boxes easy to recognize, silverplated escutcheons and pulls, a curved “serpentine” front and beaded edges. Finely crafted, they were intended to be displayed and would have been made by a cabinetmaker who also produced furniture for well-to-do households. Both Thomas Sheraton and George Hepplewhite, notable English cabinetmakers of the 18th century, included slope-lidded knife boxes in their pattern books. They were that important to the furnishing of a well-appointed home.

The second is a pair of American-made knife urns, or “butler’s urns.” If you didn’t know what they contained, you’d simply see them as skillfully turned and decorated wood objects and, maybe, wonder why they’d be placed on a sideboard in the dining room. But lift the lid—or in this case, the gilded pineapple finial—and all is revealed: the body of the urn contains circular tiers with slots for silverware. This neoclassical design also originated in England and became a favorite of Baltimore cabinetmakers.

Like the sideboards on which they stood, most knife boxes were made from mahogany or from less-expensive wood covered with mahogany veneer that was polished to a reflective sheen. While the furniture and the knife boxes weren’t necessarily made by the same craftsman at the same time, decoration, inlays and embellishments on some knife boxes echoed the decoration of the sideboard. In other instances, such as the pair of lacquered knife boxes recently offered for sale by Dutch antiques dealer A. Aardewerk Antiquair, they were meant to be art objects in their own right.

Most of the knife boxes found in American homes of the 18th century were made in England, where workshops were equipped to turn out small objects in quantity. Yet a handful of American cabinetmakers are known to have made knife boxes, and some even did this specialized work as subcontractors to larger firms.

You’re unlikely to have a knife box in active use today unless you happen to be lucky enough to own a full antique silver service and to have a household staff prepared to set your table with it. Nevertheless, knife boxes often come up for sale and at auction and can be appealing objects to own and display. They might have been made to serve a specific purpose, now obsolete, but their beauty and charm is timeless.

Leslie Gilbert Elman is the author of Weird But True: 200 Astounding, Outrageous and Totally Off the Wall Facts. She writes about antiques and other subjects for Design NJ.

“A Rich and Varied Culture: The Material World of the Early South” is a featured exhibition at the DeWitt Wallace Museum of Decorative Arts at Colonial Williamsburg highlighting art and antiques that were created in or imported to the Chesapeake, the Carolina Lowcountry and the Backcountry between 1670 and 1840. For information about Colonial Williamsburg and its museums, visit